Auction Theory : Auction and Revenue

Auctions are a widespread mechanism to allocate goods, often used by both private sellers and public institutions. While auctions can differ in format—first-price, second-price, or more exotic rules—the core issue for the seller is how much revenue the auction will generate. This concern is not limited to firms or individuals; even governments, despite their interest in efficiency, care about raising funds to avoid reliance on distortionary taxation.

A foundational result in auction theory, known as the Revenue Equivalence Theorem, states that if two auction formats always allocate the good to the same bidder, they will yield the same expected revenue under certain assumptions. For example, both the first-price and second-price auctions allocate the good to the highest bidder and thus provide, on average, the same revenue—provided that bidders behave according to the standard equilibrium strategies.

However, maximizing revenue is not always aligned with efficient allocation. A simple example illustrates this: selling two goods separately through two efficient second-price auctions generates less expected revenue than bundling the goods into a single auction. This shows that efficiency (giving the good to the highest valuer) and revenue maximization can conflict.

By the logic of the revenue equivalence theorem, no efficient auction can outperform others in revenue if they lead to the same allocation. Hence, if bundling leads to more revenue but a different allocation, the revenue-maximizing mechanism must not be efficient. This insight undermines the hope for a one-size-fits-all optimal auction.

In general, no universal auction format guarantees maximum revenue in all settings. The optimal design depends on context: bidder symmetry, risk preferences, and information structure. Yet, in standard environments—risk-neutral bidders with symmetric valuations—simple formats like the first-price auction or a second-price auction with a reserve price can still yield high expected revenue.

[https://www.learnioe.org/video/auction-and-revenue](See more...)